Sound Bite
Even on the 50th anniversary of Hawaii statehood, sovereignty in Hawaii is still the subject of an active, ongoing legal dispute. The Rights of My People revisits Liliuokalani's decades-long campaign for the dignity and sovereignty of Hawaii. The book gives the first detailed and documented description of the seizure of a quarter of the Hawaii islands in 1893. This illegal move was contested aggressively by Liliuokalani, and she challenged the United States before Congress repeatedly for complicity in taking the Crown lands. Woven into the story are threats of execution and assassination and the forces of bigotry, condescension, and deception Liliuokalani confronted.
About the Author
Neil Thomas Proto is an adjunct professor at Georgetown University’s Public Policy Institute and is of counsel at the Washington, DC law firm of Schnader Harrison Segal and Lewis.
In 1993 he drafted a unique statutory scheme at the behest of the State of Hawaii that resulted in the conveyance of Kahoolawe Island — a religious site — from the United States to Hawaii to be held in trust for native Hawaiians. The island had been used as a bombing range since 1941. He continued to represent Hawaii as counsel in its dealings with the United States through 2003. He also has lectured on Hawaii history and Kahoolawe in Hawaii (1994) and at the University of Washington Law School (2005).
Mr. Proto is a member of the board of directors of the Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt Institution. He also is the author of To A High Court, The Tumult and Choices that Led to United States of America v. SCRAP (2006).
|
About the Book
The Rights of My People reviews Liliuokalani's decades-long campaign for the dignity and sovereignty of Hawaii, particularly in the wake of the 1893 coup d'�©tat, and the outright annexation in 1898. The author gives the first detailed and...
The Rights of My People reviews Liliuokalani's decades-long campaign for the dignity and sovereignty of Hawaii, particularly in the wake of the 1893 coup d'�©tat, and the outright annexation in 1898. The author gives the first detailed and documented description of the seizure of the Crown lands, a quarter of the Hawaii islands, in 1893. This illegal move was contested aggressively by Liliuokalani for nearly two decades.With previously unexamined documents, court records, and correspondence, and with an engaging prose and graphic portrayals, author Neil Thomas Proto weaves into the story Liliuokalani's political, legal, and media maneuvering, and the exercise of her harshly learned wisdom and skill in forming and giving life to her claim that the taking of the Crown lands by the United States was immoral and illegal. The threat of execution and assassination and the continued use of religious and racial condescension and deception by her adversaries, old and new, unfold in Honolulu, Hilo, and on to the continent in San Francisco, Boston, and Washington, D.C. Over more than a decade, the queen took up residence in the nation's capital, often for months at a time, to challenge the complicity of the United States in the media and before Congress. The story ends with the lawyers' arguments and the final decision in Liliuokalani v. United States of America in 1910. In the grandeur of what is now the Renwick Art Gallery, the United States Court of Claims heard and decided the case and sealed the islands' fate; a fate that neither Liliuokalani nor her people accepted through her death in 1917. � With an easily accessible but penetrating analysis, Proto demonstrates the deliberate effort by Liliuokalani's own lawyers to denigrate her claim. The epilogue reflects the queen's intent through the end of her life to ensure persistence among her people and discomfort among those who had taken Hawaii. There is no conclusiveness or note of warmth to the ending. Through Proto's new perspective and exploration, Liliuokalani's cosmopolitan character and her place in a larger history emerge with clarity as do the continued contentiousness within Hawaii and between its native people and the United States.In 2009, the 50th anniversary of Hawaii statehood was marked.This book is especially important reading for
The Hawaiian Sovereignty Movement and other institutions concerned about pending Native Hawaiian recognition legislation and litigation including those who oppose it;Ã?ÂÂ
Hawaii's congressional delegation and staff in Washington, D.C;Ã?ÂÂ
The legal community, including the Washington D.C. Bar;Ã?ÂÂ
Universities and institutions offering Pacific region studies and American foreign and diplomatic history studies (late 19th, early 20th century);Ã?ÂÂ
Women's organizations and historians throughout the United States;Ã?ÂÂ
Civil War and Reconstruction era historians;Ã?ÂÂ
The Smithsonian Institution and the Court of Claims Historical Society;Ã?ÂÂ
Native American organizations and historians (Alaska, the Pacific, Native Americans);Ã?ÂÂ
University of Hawaii law school;
Hawaii civic organizations;
The Liliuokalani Trust,Ã?ÂÂ
The Ã? Washington Place Trust;Ã?ÂÂ
Every Hawaiian (every island; high school and above, students and faculty)
|
©2009 Book News Inc. | More »
©2009 Book News Inc.
A lawyer in Washington DC, Proto has represented Hawaii as counsel in dealing with the US government since 2003. Here, he combined his legal knowledge with his study of history to describe how the queen ousted by the 1893 coup d'etat fought legally for the return of rents and proceeds from the Crown lands on which she had lived in her former public life. From the beginning, he says, she blamed the US government for the overthrow of the constitutional monarchy and her sustenance. Among his chapters are the prescience to draw lines, the constitutionalists, the trial of Liliuokani, the principled imperative of the claim, on hallowed ground, the disquieting charade, and without counsel in the Grand Salon. The battle took place in courtrooms in Hawaii, San Francisco, and Washington.
CHOICE August 2010 Vol. 47 No. 11 | More »
CHOICE August 2010 Vol. 47 No. 11
Queen Liliuokalani was the last monarch of the Native Hawaiians before a group of US annexationists overthrew her in 1893. But before Hawai'i was annexed in 1898 by the US, she waged a heroic effort to publicize the illegality of the coup d'etat and the wrongful seizure of one million acres of crown land by the annexationists. While scholars such as Sally Engle Merry (Colonizing Hawai'i, 2000) and Jonathan Osorio (Dismembering Lahui, CH, Mar'03, 40-4207) have discussed the cultural consequences of Western law for Hawai'i, Proto (Georgetown) uses a different approach. He describes in painstaking detail the complicated maneuvering in Hawai'i and Washington as the queen sought to win public opinion, influence the media, persuade Congress, and prevail in the US courts. As a seasoned lawyer who has represented Hawai'i in its dealings with the US, Proto is able to emphasize the significance of the media campaign and legal strategies employed by Liliuokalani against her opponents to regain control of the crown lands. Sadly for the queen, her tactics were destined to fail before the Congress and the courts, with devastating consequences for Hawaiian sovereignty and her people. Fascinating narrative account, suitable for a general audience. Summing Up: Highly recommended. All levels/libraries.
F. Ng, California State University, Fresno
From the Cafe Libri
The more American history I read, the more I find myself wishing the delegates at the Hartford Convention of 1814-15 had succeeded in their aims and New England had seceded from the rest of the country and gone its own way. Certainly the people of the remaining United States would have benefited from the change. Maybe that would have helped the native Hawaiians too who, as Winston Churchill might have put it, have suffered in every respect from their association, involuntary as it was, with what author Neil Thomas Proto aptly calls the long echo of seventeenth-century Massachusetts. "The Rights of My People" is an intensely depressing book in its catalog of all the ways religious authoritarianism, racism, mercantilism, and imperialism came together to undermine and overthrow the government, denigrate and (almost) destroy the culture, and seize the land and resources of the native Hawaiians. It's an unattractive story with few heroes. But it's also educational and important for modern readers. Neil Thomas Proto does a fine job in telling it… The depth of that research is the most notable thing about Proto's work -- that and the skill with which he makes a complex and meandering legal story understandable to the lay reader… Although "The Rights of My People" is a work of history, it's also profoundly relevant to issues of today. Most obvious, of course, is the light this shines on contemporary politics in Hawaii and the issues of importance to native Hawaiians -- issues partially acknowledged but still hardly resolved by the so-called "Apology Resolution" adopted by Congress and signed by President Clinton in 1993… What the reader comes away with most strongly, though, is an understanding of that aforementioned combination of narrow religious authoritarianism, racism, and covetousness (imperial as well as economic), as well as the extent to which some people will go, then as now, to avoid ever admitting the United States could have made a mistake, let alone committed a crime. A lawyer as well as a historian, Proto is clearly arguing a point in this book, and I've no doubt some readers will react as strongly to his arguments as they have to other suggestions the US has anything to apologize for in its relations with the crown and people of Hawaii. Students of America's descent into empire will want to study these arguments closely. I think there are facts here worth knowing.
|
|
Pages 252
Year: 2009
LC Classification: DU627.18.P766
Dewey code: 996.9'027--dc22
BISAC: HIS036060 HISTORY / United States / 20th Century
BISAC: HIS036140 HISTORY / United States / State & Local / West
Soft Cover
ISBN: 978-0-87586-720-5
Price: USD 23.95
Hard Cover
ISBN: 978-0-87586-721-2
Price: USD 33.95
eBook
ISBN: 978-0-87586-722-9
Price: USD 23.95
|