Sound Bite
Francis Bacon was linked to the play The Merchant of Venice in a book published in 1965. No one has ever challenged, or further explored, that assertion. Now Christina Waldman, JD, has utilized modern research tools to examine clues from within the play itself, the works of Francis Bacon, and legal history to explore the connections.She shows how the trial scene shifts from a "law court" to "chancery court," presaging an important evolution of the English legal system that Francis Bacon had long been quietly advocating, and she has turned up countless suggestive examples of word-play along with intriguing possible historical precedents for names and symbols used in the drama, adding layers of appreciation and pleasure to the reading.
About the Book
Was Francis Bacon hiding in plain sight in The Merchant of Venice?
The old Italian jurist Bellario never appears on stage. He is too ill to come to court, so his letter introduces Portia, who argues the famous case against Shylock in disguise. The play tells us almost nothing about him. Christina G. Waldman asks: could Bellario be a disguised portrait of Francis Bacon, the brilliant Elizabethan lawyer, philosopher and future Lord Chancellor?
Building on a largely forgotten 1965 study by Mark Edwin Andrews, Waldman uses modern research tools to examine the play's remarkable command of English common law and equity. No ordinary playwright, she argues, could have understood the law at this depth. Bacon certainly could. She also explores a striking real case, Glanvill v. Courtney (1616), and its links to the play's courtroom drama.
This is the first book-length study of Bellario, and a must for anyone interested in Shakespeare, the authorship debate, or the meeting of law and literature.
Information
Building on the work of Mark Edwin AndrewsMark Edwin Andrews produced a remarkable exploration of law and equity in The Merchant of Venice in which he argued two things: that Shakespeare had a vast and profound knowledge of the English judicial system, and that the play The Merchant of Venice actually influenced that system, by influencing the results in a court case twenty years later. In Glanvill v. Courtney, a centuries-long battle for jurisdiction between the courts of law and equity came to a head and was resolved ; for a time.He also pointed out the similarity between Portia's "quality of mercy" speech and the speech Sir Bacon drafted for King James for his 1616 decree resolving the dispute over jurisdiction. To this, Christina G. Waldman has added what appears to be an even parallel from a speech Bacon made before Parliament.Andrews was writing as a law student taking a summer Shakespeare course in 1935, a time when the authorship of "Shakespeare" by the Stratford actor was simply not contested by serious scholars. It was supposed to have been a two-week project. Waldman has picked up where Andrews left off, using his extensive, meticulous research as a jumping-off place.Entwined in Andrews;¢ arguments is his assertion, essentially ignored by scholars, that Bellario, the old Italian jurist who guides the action in the play by his pre-trial advice to Portia, is none other than Francis Bacon himself. Moreover, based on her own findings, Waldman persuasively suggests that someone more than an average English lawyer/playwright, apparently Francis Bacon himself, played an authorship role in The Merchant of Venice.Today, Shakespeare's knowledge of law is no longer contested, although where he obtained it has still not been explained under orthodox theories. Waldman has searched for clues within the play itself and within the works of Francis Bacon to explore connections between Bacon and Bellario.The relationship between Bacon and Bellario has apparently never before been explored, and Bacon's contributions to Anglo-American (if not the world's) jurisprudence have been largely been overlooked in recent times. Waldman found only one reference to a potential real-life model for Bellario, Keeton's remark that Karl Elze suggested Shakespeare may have had in mind Otto Discalzio, a 16th century Paduan jurist.Andrews argued the play was set in 16th century England, in a common law courtroom, and that the last half of the play seems to switch from common law jurisdiction ; as if it were being tried in the court of King's Bench ; to equity jurisdiction ; as it were being heard in Chancery, but it was all happening in the same courtroom. That would not have happened in 16th-century England.Waldman realized the setting should be understood as 12th-century Venice, not 16th-century England, although it's likely Shakespeare intended the comparison to be made, to write something that would be useful to his own day and age. Bacon was very much an advocate of practical knowledge, and he was a student of comparative law and legal history, history in general, pretty much taking all knowledge to be his province, as he said.Waldman was able to search the plays and the works of Bacon online in a way not available to Mark Edwin Andrews in 1935. Today, no one contests the abundance and accuracy of the law in Shakespeare, but no one can explain it if Bacon's authorship is ruled out. Waldman's book shows that the appreciation of law in The Merchant of Venice is deeper, of a higher order, than just common law or civilian procedure.The research Andrews did is amazing, finding cases in the old Year Books that bore relevance to Merchant. His work was praised by several Shakespeare scholars as well as by two United States Supreme Court judges. He posed the question but left it for someone of another generation to follow up and explore it in greater depth.Maybe now, 400 years after the play was written and 80 years after Mark Edwin Andrews wrote his book, we can decipher some of the most telling clues.







Reviews
There are no reviews yet.