About the author

Scott Rutledge

Scott Rutledge earned a J.D. on top of a Master’s in mathematics and logic. A seasoned corporate attorney, he also served as an Assistant Attorney General in New Mexico and an Assistant Counsel in the Department of Housing and Urban Development. His studies and his experience give him an unusual perspective on the Supreme Court’s very tangled jurisprudence of religion.

Sacred, Mundane, Profane

A Constitutional Perspective

Price range: $19.95 through $29.95

The Constitution of the United States provides an excellent study of the uncertain boundaries between political and religious life. Its authors, as they grappled with political architecture, grappled unavoidably also with spiritual ambiguity.

Read More

Sound Bite

The U.S. Constitution was painstakingly crafted to offer guidance on questions and perennial conflicts, on issues where the secular and religious, the mundane and sacred, often flow into one another. Its authors sought to minimize ambiguities, but as they grappled with political architecture, they grappled unavoidably with spiritual ambiguity as well.The ideal of religious liberty enshrined in the Constitution stands in vivid contrast to the tendencies inherent in today’s “living constitution.” This book discusses religious liberty in the largest sense. 

About the Book

When the Supreme Court decides questions of life and death, is it acting as a court, or as a church?

Scott Rutledge begins with Gregg v. Georgia, the 1976 case on the death penalty. Lawyers arguing such cases, he notes, sound less like legal technicians than theologians or political philosophers. That observation launches a wide-ranging argument: the Supreme Court has crossed a line from interpreting the Constitution to acting as something close to a religious authority.

Rutledge treats the Constitution as a kind of secular scripture. He traces the religious choices and tensions the founders built into the documents of 1787 and 1791, and shows how the boundary between political and spiritual life has remained uncertain ever since. He then examines how the Court has expanded its power, and what Congress and citizens might do about it.

A concise, original book for readers of constitutional law, church-state relations and American political thought.

About the Book

Scott Rutledge opens with a deceptively simple question about the 1976 Supreme Court case Gregg v. Georgia: when judges decide whether to abolish the death penalty, what kind of role are they actually playing? Lawyers arguing such cases, he points out, end up sounding less like legal technicians and more like theologians or political philosophers. That observation becomes the launching point for a wide-ranging argument about how the Supreme Court has quietly crossed a line — not just interpreting the Constitution, but functioning as something closer to a religious authority.

The heart of the book treats the Constitution itself as a kind of secular scripture. Rutledge traces the religious decisions and tensions built into the original document by the Founders in 1787 and 1791, showing how concepts like justice, liberty, and the general welfare carry unavoidable spiritual weight alongside their legal meaning. The First Amendment's promise of religious liberty, he argues, was crafted deliberately to manage deep conflicts between the sacred and the mundane — conflicts that haven't gone away.

Where Rutledge gets genuinely provocative is in his claim that the Court has been usurping the legislative power of Congress by handing down decisions that are essentially religious in character while speaking the language of constitutional interpretation. For anyone frustrated by the Court's outsized political influence, or curious about where law ends and moral authority begins, this book offers a sharp and thought-provoking constitutional perspective on one of America's most enduring tensions.

Additional information

Weight N/A
Book Type Ebook, ePub, Hard cover, Soft cover
Pages

138

Release Year

LC Classification
BISAC I

POL040030 POLITICAL SCIENCE/ American Government / Judicial Branch

BISAC II

LAW111000 LAW / Judicial Power

BISAC III

LAW018000 LAW / Constitutional

Reviews

There are no reviews yet.

Be the first to review “Sacred, Mundane, Profane”

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related books